Eugenics in American law
Forced sterilisation was American law, not a fringe idea. Indiana passed the first eugenic sterilisation law in 1907; Virginia's 1924 Eugenical Sterilization Act was upheld 8-1 by the Supreme Court in Buck v. Bell (1927), where Justice Holmes wrote 'Three generations of imbeciles are enough.' More than 60,000 Americans were sterilised under such laws, about 20,000 of them in California and 7,300-8,300 in Virginia. Skinner v. Oklahoma (1942) struck down a law sterilising certain repeat criminals, but Buck v. Bell has never been overruled. Virginia (2002), California (2003) and North Carolina (2002-03) later apologised, and North Carolina (2013), Virginia (2015) and California (2021) set up compensation. In Box v. Planned Parenthood (2019), Justice Thomas argued that abortion can become 'a tool of modern-day eugenics'; the Court itself upheld Indiana's fetal-remains law and declined to decide its ban on race-, sex- and disability-selective abortions.
Virginia Eugenical Sterilization Actstatute
if now discharged or paroled would likely become by the propagation of their own kind a menace to society.
The words are the Act's own, quoted by Encyclopedia Virginia. The Act allowed superintendents of five state institutions to sterilise inmates judged to carry 'hereditary forms of insanity, imbecility, etc.' (as summarised in Buck v. Bell, 274 U.S. at 205-06). Governor E. Lee Trinkle signed it on March 20, 1924, the same day as the Racial Integrity Act. It was written to survive a court challenge, and Carrie Buck's case was brought to test it. Estimates of how many Virginians were sterilised under it range from about 7,325 to 8,300 (Virginia Register summary of DBHDS figures; Encyclopedia Virginia gives 'approximately 8,000' and, in its Buck v. Bell entry, 'about 8,300').
Buck v. Bell, Superintendent of State Colony Epileptics and Feeble Minded
Carrie Buck is a feeble minded white woman who was committed to the State Colony above mentioned in due form. She is the daughter of a feeble minded mother in the same institution, and the mother of an illegitimate feeble minded child.Majority · 274 U.S. at 205
There can be no doubt that so far as procedure is concerned the rights of the patient are most carefully considered, and as every step in this case was taken in scrupulous compliance with the statute and after months of observation, there is no doubt that in that respect the plaintiff in error has had due process at law.Majority · 274 U.S. at 207
We have seen more than once that the public welfare may call upon the best citizens for their lives. It would be strange if it could not call upon those who already sap the strength of the State for these lesser sacrifices, often not felt to be such by those concerned, in order to prevent our being swamped with incompetence. It is better for all the world, if instead of waiting to execute degenerate offspring for crime, or to let them starve for their imbecility, society can prevent those who are manifestly unfit from continuing their kind. The principle that sustains compulsory vaccination is broad enough to cover cutting the Fallopian tubes. … Three generations of imbeciles are enough.Majority · 274 U.S. at 207 (the omitted words are the citation to Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11)
Mr. Justice BUTLER dissents.Dissent · 274 U.S. at 208
The Supreme Court upheld forced sterilisation as constitutional. Holmes's line is usually quoted alone. In context it comes at the end of a paragraph arguing that the state may demand 'lesser sacrifices' from 'those who already sap the strength of the State', and that the principle behind compulsory vaccination covers 'cutting the Fallopian tubes'. Carrie Buck was 18 at trial. By her own account her pregnancy came from rape by her foster parents' nephew. Her lawyer called no witnesses. Her daughter Vivian was on her school's honour roll in 1931, a year before she died aged eight (Encyclopedia Virginia; Lombardo, Three Generations, No Imbeciles, 2008).
Skinner v. Oklahoma ex rel. Williamson, Attorney General of Oklahoma
We are dealing here with legislation which involves one of the basic civil rights of man. Marriage and procreation are fundamental to the very existence and survival of the race. The power to sterilize, if exercised, may have subtle, farreaching and devastating effects. In evil or reckless hands it can cause races or types which are inimical to the dominant group to wither and disappear. There is no redemption for the individual whom the law touches. Any experiment which the State conducts is to his irreparable injury. He is forever deprived of a basic liberty.Majority · 316 U.S. at 541
If the latter repeats his act and is convicted three times, he may be sterilized. But the clerk is not subject to the pains and penalties of the Act no matter how large his embezzlements nor how frequent his convictions.Majority · 316 U.S. at 539
The Court's first step back from Buck. It struck down Oklahoma's Habitual Criminal Sterilization Act because the Act treated near-identical crimes differently: a three-time chicken thief could be sterilised, an embezzler could not. Douglas called procreation 'one of the basic civil rights of man' and warned what sterilisation could do 'in evil or reckless hands'. But the Court cited Buck with approval and did not overrule it, so Skinner limits Buck without reversing it.
How many Americans were sterilised under eugenic lawspaper
Buck was one of more than 60,000 people who were involuntarily sterilized between 1907 and 1983.
The figure most sources use is 'more than 60,000'. Kaelber: 'compulsory sterilization laws adopted by over 30 states that led to more than 60,000 sterilizations'. Encyclopedia Virginia: 'By 1979, an estimated 60,000 people had been sterilized against their will under such laws in thirty states.' Thomas (citing Cohen): 'by 1931, 28 of the Nation's 48 States had adopted eugenic sterilization laws.' Encyclopedia Virginia also records that sterilisations rose after Buck: 'almost 28,000 Americans were sterilized' in the decade after 1927, 'compared with 8,515 between the years 1907 and 1927.' Use 'more than 60,000', and treat it as a minimum, because records are incomplete.
California: the largest programme, the 2003 apology, and the 2021 compensation fundevent
From 1909 through 1979, under state eugenics laws, thousands of people who lived in California state-run hospitals, homes and institutions were sterilized. Those laws were repealed in 1979.
Kaelber: 'In total, 20,108 people were sterilized in the state of California prior to 1964. California had by far the highest number of sterilizations in the United States (one third of all sterilizations nationwide).' He also records that the California Senate apologised in Senate Resolution No. 20 (2003) and that in March 2003 Governor Gray Davis apologised. The compensation programme was created in the 2021-22 budget (AB 137, Chapter 77, Statutes of 2021, after Assemblymember Wendy Carrillo's AB 1007). It appropriated $7.5 million, with $4.5 million split among eligible survivors. It covered both the 1909-1979 eugenics-law victims and people coercively sterilised in state prisons after 1979, and took applications from January 1, 2022 to December 31, 2023.
North Carolina: Eugenics Board 1933-1974, apology, and the 2013 compensation fundevent
From 1929 thru 1974, nearly 7,600 women and men, including boys and girls as young as ten years of age, were sterilized in North Carolina under the 1929 eugenics law and thereafter under the N.C. Eugenics Board program.
The same report: 'Females accounted for eighty-five (85) percent of sterilization victims in North Carolina. Non-whites, composed of predominantly Blacks and some Native Americans, accounted for forty (40) percent of sterilizations.' It also notes that North Carolina did most of its sterilising after World War II. Kaelber's UVM summary gives the shift over time: the Black share 'rose from 23% in the 1930s and 1940s to 59% between 1958-60 and finally to 64% between 1964 and 1966'. The task-force resolution records a formal state apology on December 12, 2002 (Kaelber also quotes Governor Easley's apology of April 17, 2003). The involuntary sterilisation law was repealed in 2003. In July 2013 the legislature set aside $10 million for verified living victims (NPR, July 25, 2013). Claims closed June 30, 2014; more than 780 people applied, and the state initially found only about 200 claims valid (WUNC, Oct. 6, 2014).
Virginia: 2002 statement of regret and apology; 2015 compensationevent
In 2002, the General Assembly passed House Joint Resolution No. 299, an official “statement of regret” honoring the memory of Carrie Buck. That same year, Governor Mark Warner offered the “Commonwealth’s sincere apology” for “the shameful effort in which state government never should have been involved.”
Warner's apology was on May 2, 2002, the 75th anniversary of Buck v. Bell. In 2015 the General Assembly approved compensation of up to $25,000 per verified living victim, or their estate (the regulation sets $25,000 per verified claim). Encyclopedia Virginia records that 28 people had claimed compensation by 2019. It also records the Washington Post editorial board's criticism that the amount was 'insulting' next to North Carolina's.
Box, Commissioner, Indiana Department of Health, et al. v. Planned Parenthood of Indiana and Kentucky, Inc., et al.
We reverse the judgment of the Seventh Circuit with respect to the first question presented, and we deny the petition with respect to the second question presented.Majority · slip op. at 1
We therefore uphold Indiana’s law under rational basis review.Majority · slip op. at 3
Our opinion likewise expresses no view on the merits of the second question presented, i.e., whether Indiana may prohibit the knowing provision of sex-, race-, and disability-selective abortions by abortion providers. Only the Seventh Circuit has thus far addressed this kind of law.Majority · slip op. at 3
Put differently, this law and other laws like it promote a State’s compelling interest in preventing abortion from becoming a tool of modern-day eugenics.Concurrence · slip op. at 2
It is true that Sanger was not referring to abortion when she made these statements, at least not directly.Concurrence · slip op. at 3
Given the potential for abortion to become a tool of eugenic manipulation, the Court will soon need to confront the constitutionality of laws like Indiana’s. But because further percolation may assist our review of this issue of first impression, I join the Court in declining to take up the issue now.Concurrence · slip op. at 4
This Court threw its prestige behind the eugenics movement in its 1927 decision upholding the constitutionality of Virginia’s forced-sterilization law, Buck v. Bell, 274 U. S. 200.Concurrence · slip op. at 7
Although Sanger was undoubtedly correct in recognizing a moral difference between birth control and abortion, the eugenic arguments that she made in support of birth control apply with even greater force to abortion.Concurrence · slip op. at 13
He explained that “the quality of the parents must be taken into account,” including “[f]eeble-mindedness,” and believed that “it should be permissible to abort any pregnancy . . . in which there is a strong probability of an abnormal or malformed infant.”Concurrence · slip op. at 14 (on Alan Guttmacher, Babies by Choice or by Chance 198 (1959))
‘We’re now concerned more with the quality of population than the quantity.’Concurrence · slip op. at 15 (quoting Guttmacher in Abortion Reforms Termed “Fantastic,” Hartford Courant, Mar. 21, 1970, p. 16)
Enshrining a constitutional right to an abortion based solely on the race, sex, or disability of an unborn child, as Planned Parenthood advocates, would constitutionalize the views of the 20th-century eugenics movement.Concurrence · slip op. at 20
I would therefore deny Indiana’s petition in its entirety.Dissent · slip op. at 2 (Ginsburg, J.)
Indiana's 2016 law did two things. It required fetal remains to be buried or cremated rather than incinerated as medical waste, and it barred providers from performing an abortion they knew was sought solely because of the child's race, sex, Down syndrome diagnosis or disability. The Court upheld the first part and declined to review the second, so the Seventh Circuit's injunction against the selective-abortion ban stayed in place. Thomas's 20-page concurrence is the opinion pro-lifers quote. It is one Justice's view, not a holding.
G07 Eugenics was a fringe pseudoscience. It's got nothing to do with mainstream America, never mind today.
G08 Clarence Gamble was a philanthropist who funded birth control around the world. Eugenics ended after the Nazis anyway.
G09 Eugenics wasn't about race. It targeted the 'unfit': the poor and disabled. Carrie Buck was white. So stop calling Sanger racist.
G10 Eugenics was the state forcing sterilisation. A woman choosing to end a pregnancy after a diagnosis like Down syndrome is a private decision. Calling that eugenics is offensive.
G11 Planned Parenthood today has nothing to do with eugenics. That's a hundred years ago. It's a healthcare provider.
E25 The Margaret Sanger thing is a smear. She was against abortion, Black leaders like W. E. B. Du Bois backed her work, and that 'exterminate the Negro population' quote is taken out of context.