Eugenics and Planned Parenthood
From America's eugenics laws to abortion today: what the record shows, what it doesn't, and why every person bears God's image.
This path tells the story in order, with sources, so you can say true things at full strength and nothing more. Part 1 is the American eugenics movement and Margaret Sanger's place in it. Part 2 is race: the Negro Project, North Carolina, and how a eugenicist can claim not to be racist. Part 3 follows Planned Parenthood into abortion and ends with the gospel. Concede what's true as you go. People trust you on the hard facts when you're honest about the soft ones.
Part 1: The movement and its founder
1. What eugenics was
Ask
Have you heard the word eugenics? What do you think it meant to the people who used it?
Read together
The point
Eugenics (a word coined by Francis Galton in 1883) was the idea that society should improve the human stock by encouraging the 'fit' to have children and stopping the 'unfit'. In 1920s America that meant the poor, the disabled, the 'feeble-minded', and often immigrants and minorities. It was respectable: the American Eugenics Society was founded in the 1920s by leading scientists and reformers, and universities taught it. The core claim is that some human lives are worth less than others and shouldn't be passed on.
They'll say
That was bad science that we've moved past. It's history.
You can answer
The science was bad, but the root wasn't a science mistake. It was a judgement about human worth, and that can outlive the science.
Practise in the Study Hub
G01 Sanger was just a woman of her time. Everyone educated believed in eugenics back then. You can't judge her by today's standards. · G07 Eugenics was a fringe pseudoscience. It's got nothing to do with mainstream America, never mind today.
2. Buck v. Bell and the American movement
Ask
Did you know the US Supreme Court once approved forced sterilisation, 8 to 1?
Read together
The point
In Buck v. Bell (1927) the Court upheld Virginia's law. Carrie Buck, a young white woman committed after a pregnancy she said came from rape, was sterilised. Justice Holmes wrote: 'Three generations of imbeciles are enough.' Paul Lombardo's research (Three Generations, No Imbeciles, 2008) showed she wasn't 'feeble-minded'; her daughter made the honour roll (Encyclopedia Virginia). Thirty-two states passed sterilisation laws between 1907 and 1937 and more than 60,000 people were sterilised. Harry Laughlin's model law shaped state laws, and Nazi Germany's 1933 sterilisation law drew on its language (University of Virginia Historical Collections); Heidelberg gave Laughlin an honorary doctorate in 1936.
They'll say
That was the Nazis' idea; America just flirted with it.
You can answer
The American laws came first. The 1933 German law drew on an American model, and Virginia apologised for its programme in 2002.
Practise in the Study Hub
G07 Eugenics was a fringe pseudoscience. It's got nothing to do with mainstream America, never mind today. · G01 Sanger was just a woman of her time. Everyone educated believed in eugenics back then. You can't judge her by today's standards.
3. Sanger's own words
Ask
Have you read what Margaret Sanger actually wrote about eugenics, rather than what people say she wrote?
Read together
The point
Sanger's The Pivot of Civilization (1922): 'The emergency problem of segregation and sterilization must be faced immediately. Every feeble-minded girl or woman of the hereditary type, especially of the moron class, should be segregated during the reproductive period.' 'A Plan for Peace', Birth Control Review, April 1932, called for 'a stern and rigid policy of sterilization and segregation to that grade of population whose progeny is tainted'. In 1926 she spoke to the women's branch of the Ku Klux Klan in Silver Lake, New Jersey (her Autobiography, 1938, p. 366). In July 2020 Planned Parenthood of Greater New York removed her name from its Manhattan clinic over her 'harmful connections to the eugenics movement' (CNN). But concede: she opposed abortion. Her 1916 flyer said 'Do not kill, do not take life, but prevent', and her autobiography says abortion 'no matter how early it was performed ... was taking life'.
They'll say
Those are cherry-picked, and she was against abortion anyway.
You can answer
Agreed she opposed abortion; she even said it takes life. The eugenics quotes are from her own book and magazine, and her own organisation acted on them in 2020.
Practise in the Study Hub
G02 Calling Sanger a eugenicist is a right-wing smear. Pro-lifers make up quotes about her all the time. · G03 The story that Sanger spoke to the Ku Klux Klan is a myth. That photo of her at a Klan rally has been debunked. · G04 Sanger opposed abortion. So pro-lifers have no business using her against Planned Parenthood. · E25 The Margaret Sanger thing is a smear. She was against abortion, Black leaders like W. E. B. Du Bois backed her work, and that 'exterminate the Negro population' quote is taken out of context.
Part 2: Race and the record
4. The Negro Project and borrowed credibility
Ask
Can I show you two documents from 1939 and ask what you think they show?
Read together
The point
In 1939 the Birth Control Federation of America launched the 'Negro Project', a birth-control programme in the South funded by Albert Lasker. Sanger wrote to Clarence Gamble in December 1939: 'We do not want word to go out that we want to exterminate the Negro population, and the minister is the man who can straighten out that idea if it ever occurs to any of their more rebellious members' (Margaret Sanger Papers Project, NYU). Gamble's memo that November, as quoted by historian Linda Gordon and, word for word, in a 2021 article defending Sanger in the House Judiciary Committee record: 'There is great danger that we will fail because the Negroes think it a plan for extermination. Hence let's appear to let the colored run it.' W. E. B. Du Bois and Mary McLeod Bethune sat on its advisory council; the proposal quoted Du Bois's own line that poor Black people 'breed carelessly and disastrously' (Birth Control Review, June 1932). The project fizzled: about 3,000 women came and no new clinics opened.
They'll say
The letter just means she wanted to stop false rumours. Black leaders backed it.
You can answer
I agree that's the fair reading of the letter, and it's no proof of genocide. But Gamble's 'appear' shows white eugenicists staging Black leadership. That's borrowed credibility, not a plot.
Practise in the Study Hub
G05 The Negro Project was a health programme run with Black leaders. The 'exterminate the Negro population' letter just shows Sanger wanted to stop false rumours. · G06 W. E. B. Du Bois and Mary McLeod Bethune backed the Negro Project, and Martin Luther King accepted the Margaret Sanger Award. Are you saying they were dupes? · E25 The Margaret Sanger thing is a smear. She was against abortion, Black leaders like W. E. B. Du Bois backed her work, and that 'exterminate the Negro population' quote is taken out of context.
5. Gamble and North Carolina
Ask
Do you know which state kept sterilising people into the 1970s, and who it ended up targeting?
Read together
The point
Clarence Gamble, grandson of Procter & Gamble co-founder James Gamble and later founder of the Pathfinder Fund (1957), was a founding member of North Carolina's Human Betterment League in 1947, which promoted sterilisation (NCpedia). North Carolina's Eugenics Board approved 6,802 sterilisations from 1933 to 1966 (Dartmouth, Eugenic States); a state task force estimated about 7,600 from 1929 to 1974. Black people were 23% of those sterilised in the 1930s-40s and 64% in 1964-66, and by the later 1960s 99% were women (Lutz Kaelber, University of Vermont). In 1973 Minnie Lee and Mary Alice Relf, aged 12 and 14, were sterilised at a federally funded clinic in Montgomery, Alabama, after their mother was told she was signing for birth-control shots (Relf v. Weinberger). In 2013 North Carolina set aside $10 million to compensate victims.
They'll say
That was the state, not Planned Parenthood or Sanger.
You can answer
Right, and I won't blame Sanger for NC. But the man who funded and ran the Negro Project campaigned for this programme. It shows what that circle believed.
Practise in the Study Hub
G08 Clarence Gamble was a philanthropist who funded birth control around the world. Eugenics ended after the Nazis anyway.
6. How can a eugenicist claim not to be racist?
Ask
If a programme sterilised poor white people and poor Black people alike, would that make it fair?
Read together
The point
The defence is real: eugenics mainly targeted the 'unfit' (poor, disabled, 'feeble-minded'), Carrie Buck was white, early NC victims were mostly white, and many historians argue Sanger wasn't racist in the usual sense. Grant it. Then show why it fails: it still ranks human worth. Once some lives count less, race, class and disability are just ways of sorting who, which is how NC moved to mostly Black women without changing its law. The same logic appears today when a prenatal diagnosis such as Down syndrome is treated as a reason not to let a child be born; in 1959 Alan Guttmacher argued abortion should be allowed where there is 'a strong probability of an abnormal or malformed infant' (quoted in Box v. Planned Parenthood, 2019, Thomas, J., concurring).
They'll say
It was about health and poverty, not race. Calling it racist is lazy.
You can answer
Fine, drop the word. The substance is worse: deciding which people should exist. That's what Scripture forbids for anyone.
Practise in the Study Hub
G09 Eugenics wasn't about race. It targeted the 'unfit': the poor and disabled. Carrie Buck was white. So stop calling Sanger racist. · G10 Eugenics was the state forcing sterilisation. A woman choosing to end a pregnancy after a diagnosis like Down syndrome is a private decision. Calling that eugenics is offensive.
Part 3: From contraception to abortion, and the gospel
7. Guttmacher and the move to abortion
Ask
Do you know who led Planned Parenthood when it started backing legal abortion?
Read together
The point
Alan Guttmacher was president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America from 1962 to 1968 and had been a vice-president of the American Eugenics Society. He founded the Association for the Study of Abortion in 1964. In 1970 he told the Hartford Courant: 'We're now concerned more with the quality of population than the quantity' (quoted in Box v. Planned Parenthood, 2019). Planned Parenthood leaders backed repeal of abortion laws from 1969; in 1970, the day after New York's new law took effect, its Syracuse affiliate became the first Planned Parenthood centre to provide abortions; after Roe v. Wade (1973) abortion became a core service. In the early 1970s the American Eugenics Society renamed itself the Society for the Study of Social Biology.
They'll say
Guttmacher was a doctor who saw women die from illegal abortions. That's why he backed legalisation.
You can answer
That was part of his motive, and it's a real concern. But his own words show 'quality of population' was part of it too. Both can be true.
Practise in the Study Hub
G11 Planned Parenthood today has nothing to do with eugenics. That's a hundred years ago. It's a healthcare provider. · G04 Sanger opposed abortion. So pro-lifers have no business using her against Planned Parenthood.
8. The numbers today
Ask
Can I show you the CDC's figures by race, and you tell me what you'd call them?
Read together
The point
CDC Abortion Surveillance, 2022 (MMWR, November 2024): among areas reporting race, non-Hispanic Black women had 39.5% of reported abortions, a rate of 24.4 per 1,000 women aged 15-44 against 5.7 for white women, 4.3 times higher. Black Americans are about 13-14% of the population. Planned Parenthood's 2023-24 annual report counts 402,230 abortions in its reporting year, making it the largest US provider. Most researchers explain the racial gap by unintended pregnancy, poverty and access to care, not targeting.
They'll say
It's about poverty and unintended pregnancy. Calling it genocide is offensive.
You can answer
I agree it isn't proven intent, so I won't say genocide. But poverty is a reason to help the mother, not to accept that Black children die at four times the rate.
Practise in the Study Hub
G12 Saying abortion is 'Black genocide' is offensive. The racial gap is about poverty and unintended pregnancy, not anyone targeting Black women. · E25 The Margaret Sanger thing is a smear. She was against abortion, Black leaders like W. E. B. Du Bois backed her work, and that 'exterminate the Negro population' quote is taken out of context.
9. The step-by-step shift
Ask
Do you think big moral changes happen all at once, or in small steps that each seem reasonable?
Read together
The point
What's documented: a founder who opposed abortion but backed eugenic sterilisation; leaders like Guttmacher who were eugenicists and argued for legal abortion; abortion from 1970; now the largest provider. What isn't: one coordinated 50-year plan. Useful terms: the Overton window (Joseph Overton, Mackinac Center, mid-1990s), the range of ideas the public will accept, which shifts over time; incrementalism, change in small steps; the foot-in-the-door effect (Freedman and Fraser, 1966), agreeing to a small request makes a bigger one easier. A slippery-slope argument is valid when you show the mechanism. Carl Trueman's The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self (Crossway, 2020) offers a better frame than conspiracy: a shared logic in which the self is defined by its desires, so an unwanted child becomes a problem.
They'll say
That's a slippery-slope conspiracy theory.
You can answer
No plan needed, and I'm not claiming one. Each step is on the record; the same idea kept moving. Which step do you think isn't documented?
Practise in the Study Hub
G13 This 'from eugenics to abortion' story is a slippery-slope conspiracy theory. You're connecting dots that aren't connected.
10. Making the case without overclaiming
Ask
Can I tell you what I won't say about Sanger, before I tell you what I will?
Read together
The point
Don't say: Sanger promoted abortion; the 'exterminate' letter proves genocide; Sanger called Black people 'human weeds' (fabricated); the photo of her at a Klan rally (fake, PolitiFact 2020); 'breed carelessly' was Sanger's (it was Du Bois's); 'Black Americans would be 37-40% of the population'; PP was founded to wipe out Black people. Do say: she was a committed eugenicist in her own words; she spoke to a KKK women's group (her autobiography); the Negro Project's organisers planned to borrow Black credibility; its funder campaigned for North Carolina's sterilisations; PP's abortion-era leader was a eugenicist; the racial gap today is real (CDC). And remember the main argument isn't the founder at all; it's what the unborn child is (E01).
They'll say
So you admit half the pro-life talking points are wrong.
You can answer
Some are, and I'd rather lose a talking point than say something false. What's left is plenty, and it's all checkable.
Practise in the Study Hub
E25 The Margaret Sanger thing is a smear. She was against abortion, Black leaders like W. E. B. Du Bois backed her work, and that 'exterminate the Negro population' quote is taken out of context. · G02 Calling Sanger a eugenicist is a right-wing smear. Pro-lifers make up quotes about her all the time. · G05 The Negro Project was a health programme run with Black leaders. The 'exterminate the Negro population' letter just shows Sanger wanted to stop false rumours. · E01 It's just a clump of cells.
11. The gospel: every human made in God's image
Ask
Where do you think human worth comes from, if not from being useful or wanted?
Read together
The point
Eugenics, old and new, measures people by usefulness or wantedness. Scripture says worth is given, not earned: God made every person in his own image (Genesis 1:27), knits each one together in the womb (Psalm 139), made every nation from one man (Acts 17:26), and makes us one in Christ whatever our race or status (Galatians 3:28). The gospel goes further: Christ died for us while we were still sinners (Romans 5:8), not because we were fit, but because we weren't. That's good news for the 'unfit', for the unborn, and for anyone who has taken part in abortion and needs forgiveness.
They'll say
That's your religion. Secular people value human life too.
You can answer
Many do, and I'm glad. But on what basis, if worth depends on ability or being wanted? That's exactly the basis eugenics used. The image of God gives a floor no one can fall below.
Practise in the Study Hub
E01 It's just a clump of cells. · G09 Eugenics wasn't about race. It targeted the 'unfit': the poor and disabled. Carrie Buck was white. So stop calling Sanger racist. · G10 Eugenics was the state forcing sterilisation. A woman choosing to end a pregnancy after a diagnosis like Down syndrome is a private decision. Calling that eugenics is offensive.